real-dark-knight wrote:
Nice review Caleson - I'd say you got it bang on!

I've not seen the commetary of This Little Piggy - but there is no doubt that when you get that insight on where people are coming from, it can make a BIG difference! You wouldn't think so, but it does! I remember how the commentary of Critters on BTAS 4 boxset completely changed my mind about the whole episode..........

I don't recall the problems with flying vehicles animation that you talk of, but I could've just missed it.

I personally thought the diversity of characters in JLU went a bit too far; and I'd rather have seen more Batman, Superman, WW etc - but the other side of the coin is characters I really like got a look in; We get to know Green Arrow pretty well, and even Jonah Hex pops up (in one of the BEST episodes of all!).

Even with the (thoughtful) criticisms I've detailed above; and taking into account your drawbacks - I also think it's a thoroughly essential purchase..............

Good stuff.

PS - it was a mainly because I wanted to talk about Timm & Dini stuff that I came to BYTB! I think I just searched on Google and found the forums (and wanted to join in!)

*********************************

THIS IS A REPLY TO CALESON'S JLU REVIEW (OR AT LEAST IT SHOULD'VE BEEN) - IF YOU WANT TO TALK ABOUT IT, PLEASE POST IT THERE, NOT HERE...........

real-dark-knight wrote:
I personally thought the diversity of characters in JLU went a bit too far; and I'd rather have seen more Batman, Superman, WW etc - but the other side of the coin is characters I really like got a look in; We get to know Green Arrow pretty well, and even Jonah Hex pops up (in one of the BEST episodes of all!).